Is a 1200-Calorie Diet (or Any Super Low-Calorie Diet) Actually Realistic?
In the quest for quick weight loss, 1200-calorie diets and other very low-calorie diets (VLCDs) are often touted as a fast track to dropping pounds. But are these super restrictive plans actually sustainable, healthy, and effective over the long run? Or are they setting dieters up for frustration, malnutrition, and inevitable weight regain?
Below we’ll take an in-depth look at 1200-calorie diets, other VLCD approaches, and whether they are realistic strategies for lasting success.
What is a 1200-Calorie Diet?
A 1200-calorie diet, as its name implies, limits daily caloric intake to around 1200 calories per day. Some versions allow for a range closer to 1000-1400 calories. But the basis is severely slashing calories below the typical recommended daily intake of 2000 calories for women and 2500 for men.
1200-calorie plans rose to fame with the publication of diet books like “8 Minutes in the Morning for Real Shapes Real Sizes” by Jorge Cruise. They often promise rapid weight loss results of 10 pounds or more per month if adhered to strictly.
1200 calories doesn’t provide much wiggle room. It allows only about 3 modest meals of 400 calories each. No extra bites, tastes, or snacks are permitted. Followers must be very mindful of portion sizes and diligent calorie counters.
Going below 1200 calories crosses into potentially dangerous territory for most adults. So 1200 calories marks the lowest acceptable threshold for an ongoing diet strategy.
Can You Lose Weight on 1200 Calories?
Yes, when calories are restricted to around 1200 per day, you will definitely lose weight, at least in the short term. That degree of calorie deprivation makes fast initial weight loss nearly inevitable.
However, the rate of loss depends on variables like your height, weight, age, and activity level. Very petite, sedentary women may see a loss of 1-2 pounds per week. Larger, active individuals may drop 4 pounds or more per week at the start.
This rapid initial drop excites many dieters. But be aware – much of the weight shed is water and carbs stored in muscles, not all fat.
Once the body’s water weight normalizes and you lose muscle mass from inadequate protein and calories, the rate of weight loss slows on 1200-calorie diets. At that point, losing just 1/2 to 1 pound per week is considered safe and sustainable.
Problems and Health Risks with 1200-Calorie Diets
Sure, restricting to just 1200 calories daily leads to quick weight loss at first. But there are many downsides to maintaining intake this low for extended periods:
– Nutrient deficiencies – 1200 calories makes getting 100% of all your daily vitamins, minerals and protein tough. Nutritional shortfalls can cause issues like hair loss, fatigue, infertility or anemia over time.
– Loss of lean mass – Extreme calorie restriction causes breakdown of calorie-burning muscle. This slows metabolism.
– Extreme hunger – Appetite-suppressing hormones like leptin plummet on very low-calorie diets, amplifying hunger and cravings. This makes compliance difficult.
– Binge risk – Deprivation this severe often leads to binging when willpower fades. Bingeing negates previous calorie restriction.
– Metabolic adaptation – The body counters ongoing calorie cuts by decreasing calorie expenditure. This is the dreaded “starvation mode” plateau.
– Gallstones – Rapid weight loss increases gallstone risk. Gallstones can cause severe pain, nausea, and require surgery to remove.
– Nutritional deficiencies – Cutting calories without guidance often leads to vitamin, mineral and protein deficiencies over time.
– Fatigue – Very low calories lead to both physical and mental exhaustion. Lack of fuel impairs concentration.
– Irritability – Hunger and exhaustion take a toll on mood. Brain fog, anxiety, depression and irritability are common.
– Disordered eating – For those prone to eating disorders, extreme calorie plans may trigger unhealthy behaviors.
– Weight regain – Within 1-5 years, nearly all lost weight is regained. Dieting ruins metabolism making future loss harder.
In short, 1200 calories or fewer is nearly impossible to keep up safely or realistically for good health, energy and sane appetite levels.
Health Risks of Other Very Low Calorie Diets
Along with 1200 calorie diets, other examples of very low calorie diets include:
– 800 calories or fewer per day
– Liquid diets providing 800 calories or less
– Very low-calorie shake programs
– Extreme calorie restriction like the 5:2 diet
– Super low-carb diets under 50g daily
– Fasting regimens
Any eating plan that cuts calories under the minimum of 1200 daily for women and 1500 for men can pose health risks similar to those above if followed for an extended period.
Potential problems include electrolyte imbalances, irregular heartbeat, anemia, fertility issues, hair loss, gallstones, and more. Vitamin and mineral supplementation is critical to avoid deficiencies.
Medical supervision is highly advised for diets providing fewer than 800 calories per day, as serious complications can arise.
So Who Can Actually Maintain a 1200-Calorie Diet?
For most adults following a 1200-calorie diet for ongoing weight loss and maintenance is NOT medically recommended or realistically sustainable.
However, there are some exceptions where a 1200-calorie intake could be appropriate:
– Petite, sedentary women – Some very short, inactive women require less than 2000 calories per day for maintenance at a healthy weight. Their calorie needs for moderate weight loss could dip close to 1200 calories.
– Nutritionally replete – If someone has highly nutritious eating habits, 1200 calories may provide sufficient nutrition for brief time periods with medical guidance.
– Medically supervised – With medical monitoring for vitamin levels, bone density, heart health, etc. some may safely restrict this low temporarily.
But for most adults, cutting to just 1200 calories daily long-term is likely to jeopardize nutrient status, health, energy levels, appetite control, and sanity. It is not realistic for permanent weight management.
Strategies for Healthy, Sustainable Weight Loss
Since super restrictive diets like the 1200-calorie plan are unrealistic for most people, what are some healthier strategies for lasting weight loss?
Here are some recommended evidence-based approaches:
– Gradually reduce calories – Cut just 300-500 calories from your maintenance level for slower but steady loss.
– Eat high volume – Focus on foods with low calorie density to get more volume and feel full.
– Protein at each meal – Eat around 30g protein foods at each meal to support muscle and satisfy hunger.
– Move more – Add movement through steps, exercise, standing, fidgeting. Don’t just diet.
– Lift weights – Retain and build calorie-burning lean muscle mass through resistance training.
– Set mini goals – Aim for modest loss each week rather than rapid short-term drop.
– Stress management – Manage cortisol to minimize stress-driven overeating and cravings.
– Sleep well – Poor sleep increases hunger hormones making eating restraint harder.
– Limit processed foods – Whole foods keep hunger in check and provide more nutrients per calorie.
– Stay consistent – Steady healthy habits are key versus extreme short term restriction.
With a few small daily changes, 1-2 pounds per week can be lost effectively without depriving yourself or tanking your metabolism. Patience and persistence are critical!
Healthy Low-Calorie Diet Tips
If you do opt to reduce your calorie intake for weight loss, be sure to make every calorie count nutrient-wise. Here are some tips:
– Meet protein needs first – Prioritize lean proteins at each meal for satiety and muscle retention.
– Eat plenty of produce – Focus on low-calorie fruits and veggies to boost volume and nutrients.
– Choose whole grains – For lasting energy and fiber, emphasize whole grains like oats, brown rice, quinoa.
– Healthy fats – Include omega-3 rich fats from fatty fish, avocado, nuts and seeds.
– Stay hydrated – Drink water, unsweetened tea and coffee. Limit liquid calories.
– Take a multi-vitamin – For nutritional insurance to prevent deficiencies.
– Move daily – Walking, strength training and activity supports muscle and metabolism.
– Sleep 7-9 hours – Adequate sleep prevents surges in hunger hormones.
– Manage stress – Keep cortisol in check to prevent stress-driven overeating.
The healthiest diets cut calories through wholesome minimally processed foods, activity, hydration, and sleep – not deprivation.
Sample 1200-Calorie Diet Meal Plan
If you do choose to follow a 1200-calorie diet, be sure to make them count nutritionally. Here is a sample daily meal plan:
Breakfast – 250 calories
– 1⁄2 cup oatmeal cooked in water with 1⁄2 cup blueberries
– 1 hardboiled egg
– Small latte made with 1 cup nonfat milk
Lunch – 400 calories
– Turkey sandwich on 2 slices whole grain bread with lettuce, tomato, mustard
– 1 cup low-sodium vegetable soup
– 1 medium apple
Dinner – 500 calories
– 4 ounces baked cod
– 1 cup steamed broccoli
– 1⁄2 cup brown rice
– Tossed salad with 2 Tbsp light dressing
Snacks – 50 calories
– 1 part-skim mozzarella cheese stick
This supplies balanced nutrition all within 1200 calories – but it requires diligent weighing and measuring of all foods and strict avoidance of additional tastes and bites. For most people, it’s not a sustainable lifelong approach.
The Takeaway
Can you lose weight rapidly on a 1200-calorie diet or other very low-calorie plans? Certainly. But do these overly restrictive approaches lead to lasting success and health for most people? Unfortunately not.
Cutting calories recklessly low without a strong foundation of nutrition, exercise, stress control, and patience is a recipe for failure in the long run. And it can jeopardize your health and sanity in the process.
Slow and steady triumphs over drastic! Focus on modest calorie reduction coupled with increased wholesome foods, activity, and improved sleep and stress balance. Small changes made consistently in a real-world sustainable way help you shed pounds and cultivate healthy habits that keep weight off permanently.
About The Author
